Your comment may need to be approved before it will appear on the site. Thanks for waiting. First time commenting? Please review the Comment Policy.
One of the best pies I’ve ever made! I followed your directions for store-bought blackberries, and it was absolutely perfect. I will be making this again.
it’s Berry Berrylicious!!!
To those who found it soupy….just drain off the excess and put the berries in the pie.
I put the mixture together and let it sit overnight in the fridge. The “soup” from the berries can then be made into a sauce over the pie and icecream.
OMG is it ever good. I did the crust from your recipe as well, it tastes good but I had a little challenge to stop it from crumbling. Thank you for sharing this. My husband love it!Cornelia
Perfection! I really wanted to make a blackberry pie for my friends who were visiting to show off the amazing blackberries growing around Seattle right now. This recipe was exactly what I was looking for! I followed it precisely, picked a few under ripe berries as instructed and it was magnificent! It set beautifully and received rave reviews from everyone at the table. Thank you!
Really disappointed. Was so excited to make this after we picked fresh blackberries at the farmers market. I followed the directions exactly for the fresh picked berries and it turned out runny and soupy. I bake a lot and have never had that happen! Bummer!
Excellent! My husband doesn’t care for a lot of crust so I made pie crust squares and then made the filling on the stovetop. I mixed all the ingredients except thickener and let it simmer for about 15 – 20 mins. I thickened the berries with a cornstarch/water mixture. Cinnamon added a great taste. We topped vanilla ice cream with the blackberries and a piece of crust. Will make this again!!
What a great idea BKB, thanks for sharing!
This is the best blackberry pie I’ve ever made!
We loved it. Used fresh from the vine berries so added more cornstarch. It was not too sweet. Just perfect!!
I’ve made this several times now with our own fresh picked berries. It’s one of my favorites! The almond extract takes the filling to another level! Pure yumminess!
Love this recipe! I just made it and it turned out perfect!
Totally soupy and way too sweet! You need way more than 4 tablespoons of flour if using store bought blackberries. I should’ve read the comments before making it. There should be a note in the recipe to use 5 or 6 tablespoons of flour not 3 to 4.
Hi Allie, you’re right! There really is a difference between store-bought berries and wild picked berries. I’ve adjusted the recipe to account for the difference. Thank you for your feedback!
Hi. So my family went blackberry picking and really wanted to make a pie. So I made one with my younger sibling and it came out super runny. It tastes really good but would definitely make sure you have no extra liquid or add more cornstarch for further making.
Hi Serena, thank you for your feedback! I’ve adjusted the recipe so that it is more clear that you should include a few less-than ripe berries if you are using wild berries, and a little more thickener.
Didn’t have almond extract, but it was so very, very good! Will be saving this one!
Came out perfectly. Used frozen blackberries and topped with ice cream when served
I love that you mention our American River! I’ve spent many days wandering along the banks picking and eating berries right off the vine. I actually bought 3 bare root thornless blackberry plants (Triple Crowns but i’m glad to hear you had good luck with the Navi’s in our climate) 2 years ago. They gave berries last year, but barely a couple handfulls. This year though…holy cow…they are literally covered with berries! I can’t wait to use them in your recipe. I’ve had about a dozen ripen already, but the bulk are still in that awkward reddish black phase…a few more weeks and it will be pie heaven time!
I used 4 cups of fresh picked blackberries with a few with red still on them. I added every other ingredient just as directed. I also cooked the pie about 20 minutes longer but that may just be my oven. It was not runny at all and i could pick it up with my hand for the most part. Oh! and cornstarch instead of tapioca.
Blackberry bushes surround me. I live in Paradise CA. I have been making pies using a similiar recipe for 20 years. It’s a good one !!
Great recipe! I used fresh wild blackberries. Yum! Perfect consistency, but I used between 4 & 5 Tbsp of cornstarch (slightly more than the recipe called for). Also, instead of doing two equally-timed cooking stages, I baked mine at 425 F for ~15min and then dropped the temperature to 375 F for ~20-30 min (or until crust golden brown and filling is bubbling). Would definitely recommend and make again someday! :)
Hi, just a quick trick i learned for making blueberry pie, use the tappioca as directed, but i also grate a peeled granny smith apple in. The apple has natural pectin and absorbs the berry flavor creating a thickener without adding a pastey taste. I cook about half the berries and sugar crushing afew in the pan, cool add to berries and apples then continue with pue recipe. Good luck
Totally soupy. Needs more tapioca/flour. Really yummy though. I added Quatre Epices French Four Spice and it smelled and tasted awesome!
Hi Kathy, it all depends on the type of blackberries you are using. If you use wild blackberries, many of them are underripe and therefore have more pectin. If you use market berries, or defrosted frozen berries, they won’t have as much pectin and therefore will need more thickener.
Two of my kids helped me (dad) pick several cups of blackberries I found hiking one day. They were all ripe and purple. We have scratches to prove it! I followed the recipe and it looked awesome until I cut into it and it was super watery–still tasted great–but didn’t set up. I guess I needed more cornstarch? I didn’t have the tapioca thickener, but it cooked down really soupy. I love blackberry pie in any form though!
Hi Jon, it’s a good idea to include a few not quite perfectly ripe blackberries in the mix. They have more pectin and will help with the set. Otherwise yes, just use more cornstarch.
As I was reading the step on rolling out the pie crust, In step number 2 I found a teeeny weeeny little mistake in your instructions. I tried to roll out the bottom crust after I put it I the fridge, but it was already in the pie tin!! I figured it out, and I’m waiting on the results. Kurt
Good catch Kurt, thank you! Fixed.
I made this and followed the recipe thoroughly and it was a soupy mess! Very disappointed as I bake all the time!
Hi Suzanne, did you use wild picked berries or store bought? Wild picked, especially if some of them are a little less ripe, will yield a firmer result because there is more pectin in less ripe berries. If you use store-bought super ripe berries, you’ll probably need to add a tablespoon or more of a thickener.
Looks fantastic. I’m looking for a pie recipe to use my blackberries. I have them growing out my ears.
I used your filling recipe along with another one. Yours used less tapioca which I believe was just right. There’s used more lemon juice which I liked. I have to say I did not care for the almond extract. I felt it took the freshness away from the berries. Not sure how else to explain. I think if I was making the pie in the winter I would like the almond. I plan to make this again in a couple days for my friend(minus the almond extract). I can’t wait!!! Thank you for sharing your recipe.
I made this pie last night, and it was amazing. My blackberry bush has gone haywire this season producing large quantities of blackberries. So far I’ve made jars and jars of preserves, a cobbler and a pie, but now that I’ve made THIS pie, I’ll be freezing whatever more blackberries I can get from the bush to make this pie throughout the winter! I used the pre-made boxed refrigerated pie crusts, but brushed them with melted unsalted butter and sprinkled with sugar. YUM-O!
After picking lots ans lots of black berries this weekend it is pie time! I hope mine looks a great as yours! Hope you are doing well!
Hi Mark, all is very well here, thank you! A note on the pie, if you include a few of the blackberries that still have a bit of red in them, they’ll help the pie firm up. Those red ones have lots of pectin.
Had 6 cups of juicy blackberries and I made this great pie. Next time I think I will leave the lemon zest out though, maybe even no lemon at all. It overshadowed the blackberry. It did set up very well though, clean cut peices, not soupy at all.
I’m planning to try this recipe tomorrow. Previous comments of “too dry” and “too soupy” have me wondering — how do you know if you have enough tapioca for your specific berries? Can you tell by how it is looking prior to baking or is it a learned skill to judge your berries versus tapioca requirements?
Sometimes it is really hard to tell. If you can’t deal with “soupy” and don’t want to risk it, add more thickener. It also helps if you make sure the pie cools down entirely before serving it. Almost any pie warm risks being soupy.
I learned to trick from a babysitter of mine many years ago. She taught me to get my berries ready with the sugar and the lemon juice etc. let them sit for about a half hour to get juicy. Mix cornstarch with a bit of water until it’s a nice pasty consistency. Remove half of the juicy berries with some of the juice and put them in a pan on the stove, Bring to a boil. Stir in cornstarch mix until thick – stirring constantly.
Mix the fresh berries into the thickened berries add them to the piecrust. I have found this rarely fails me regardless of the type of berries. It is worth the time when you’re making a pie that is unpredictable as blackberry often is.
I picked fresh blackberries today and followed the recipe exact, but my pie was like soup! I have no idea what I did wrong. I’ve made all kinds of pies, although I have never made a blackberry pie, and this has never happened. What could I have done wrong? I have no idea??
It could be that your fresh blackberries were particularly plump and juicy. In which case you would need to add more thickener. We’re using instant tapioca for a thickener in this recipe, but you could also use flour or cornstarch.
I will be making this for our Thanksgiving feasts we have been invited to. I scored 55 lbs of the sweetest blackberries on an amazing sale of $1/12oz. So I froze them all on sheet pans to keep them whole and then tossed them into freezer bags. Now I have enough blackberries to last over a year!
Thanks for this delicious recipe. Last week, I tried a different online blackberry pie recipe. It was a disaster (ugly, soupy and sour). I am a novice pie maker, and almost swore off pies forever. I love blackberries though, so I decided to give it another try. The pie turned out great. I am in love.
I made this pie yesterday after coming home from the Farmer’s Market with way too many blackberries. It was delicious – thank you Elise!! And the pie crust was one of the easiest recipes I have worked with. What are your thoughts on using the exact same recipe and using blueberries, or any other kind of fruit? Do you think it would work as well or would quantities have to be changed?
You could try it with other fruit. We have a good blueberry pie recipe on the site which is similar too. ~Elise
Well, I have to say that I found the recipe intriguing enough to have followed it to the letter. All I can say is I never knew of my Grandmother using cinnamon, almond extract, or lemon juice/zest in her blackberry pie….I now know why…. :(
Made this recently and it was so good!
Made this pie tonight with blackberries picked today. It was excellent! The combo of lemon, cinnamon and almond really liven up the blackberries, in a very subtle way. I also used afew drops of almond extract (due to lack of amaratto) in an egg white wash on the bottom crust. It was plenty sweet and the consistency was perfect, even when not completely cooled. It tasted even better once it was thoroughly cooled.
I used 6 cups of berries because I like a thick pie and used a generous amount of crumb topping instead of a pastry top.
Mix together 1/2 C white sugar, 1/4 C brown sugar, 3/4 C flour, 1 tsp cinnamon, cut in 1/2 C butter. This filling with the crumb topping was delicious.
It took closer to 1 1/2 hours for the pie to bake completely and I covered it with foil for the last half hour or so. I highly recommend this version of blackberry pie and I’m pretty sure I will be making it again before the season is over.
I made this recipe last night. Everything but the almond extract. AMAZING!
I’m wondering if raspberries can be substituted for blackberries. We picked almost 20 pounds of red raspberries and I’m running our of ideas.
Great question, I don’t know! Raspberries freeze well, and if I had 20 pounds, I would freeze as much as I could. They cook up so well with a little sugar into a lovely sauce for cheesecake, chocolate cake, or ice cream. ~Elise
I made the Blackberry pie for 3 different occasions. It is s-i-m-p-l-y wonderful!!! I didn’t have the time to make the crust, so I used the refrigerated pie crusts instead. Whipped up an egg white together with a heaping “slosh” of Amaretto and brushed that on the bottom crust. Added the berry mix. Made a lattice crust for the top, slathered more of the egg white wash over it and then sprinkled cinnamon sugar over all of it. Each of the 3 times, it was totally “devoured.” 5 *’s in my opinion.
I tried this recipe (picture here!) but my pie came out kind of dry… any idea why? Maybe my grocery store blackberries just weren’t juicy enough? Your pie looks so good, and I had really high hopes for this, but it was somewhat disappointing.
Sounds like your blackberries were a little dry to begin with. Recipes are just guidelines by the way. Fruit varies so much by batch, that it’s kind of hard to get it just right. Partly you have to go with feel, considering the batch of fruit you are using. You can always use less (or more) tapioca. Less if the fruit is a little dry, more if it’s liquidy. ~Elise
Love the Blackberry Pie – but as Randi said – can’t have the seeds (in my case it’s my mom’s dentures) so I cook the berries and juice ’em – run them through the sieve and then the cheesecloth to get all the seeds out. Then I use either cornstarch and butter to thicken it, or tapioca flour, really whatever works. It makes a delicious “jelly” pie that anyone can eat. Instead of the top crust I use whipped cream. But the cinnamon is a must! Haven’t tried the almond extract, but it could be yummy too :)
I have lived in Sacramento my whole life. Are the blackberries just everywhere along the river? or can you give a few basic ideas?
They are everywhere. All along the bike trail. I don’t think you can bike a half mile on the trail without encountering at least one huge patch. Though you’ll need to go on one of the dirt trails to find a bush that isn’t well picked. Just keep your eye out this time of year for rattlesnakes. Don’t walk willy nilly into the brush. ~Elise
Inspiration! I came home from the farmer’s market with 3 baskets of dead ripe blackberries this morning, but no real plan. Didn’t feel up to pie crust, but followed this recipe for filling and added a streusel-crisp topping. It’s about to come out of the oven, to be served with a little homemade vanilla ice cream.
I have 4 one lb bags of blackberries in the freezer @ $1.01 each a few weeks ago. I am glad to see others like cinnamon and almond extract in berry pies. I use a mix of cornstarch and tapioca to thicken my berry pies. I have also used Clearjel from King Arthur flour–adds fewer carbs and that is a must for our type 2 diabetic family.
I also like to make cobbler and use frozen biscuits on top. I make a half recipe as I am cooking for a small number of people these days.
It is extra hot today in ATL–again. The oven will be turned on about midnight and several things will be made for the coming week. Two small blackberry pies will be in that oven.
@ 114º humi temp, I can cook bacon and eggs on my sidewalk. Wonder how long it would take to bake a pie in a solar oven; Girl Scout style?
I’ve got a bag of TJ frozen berries in the freezer. Conventional pie crust is out for me because of the gluten and the starch, but I’ll try your recipe for filling with a coconut flour cobbler topping, which is both GF and LC.
I wonder what this would be like if I strained the mixture through a large holed sieve to get the seeds out? My teeth have been breaking alot lately (a medical reason) and I’m scared to bite on anything hard. I’m guessing it would have to be thickened a bit more.
I’ve never had a black berry pie, only blueberry, but yours looks lovely. If I use frozen berries they would have to be drained, right?
Yes, defrost and drain. ~Elise